Building an M&A Pipeline

A robust M&A pipeline is the foundation of successful corporate development. This guide covers how to systematically source, qualify, track, and engage potential acquisition targets.

What is an M&A Pipeline?

An M&A pipeline is a structured inventory of potential acquisition targets at various stages of evaluation and engagement. Think of it as a sales CRM, but for acquisitions.

Pipeline Stages (typical):

  1. Universe: All companies matching basic criteria
  2. Long List: Companies worth initial research
  3. Short List: Prioritized targets for outreach
  4. Active Engagement: In discussions with target
  5. Due Diligence: Formal evaluation underway
  6. Negotiation: Terms being finalized
  7. Closed: Deal completed

Building the Initial Universe

Top-Down Market Screening

Approach: Start with market sizing and work down to individual companies

Steps:

  • Define target markets/sectors based on M&A strategy
  • Identify all companies in those markets
  • Apply basic filtering criteria (size, geography, business model)
  • Rank by strategic fit and attractiveness

Data Sources:

  • CorpDev.Ai, PitchBook, Crunchbase, CB Insights (private companies)
  • Capital IQ, FactSet, Bloomberg (public companies)
  • Industry associations and databases
  • Government business registries
  • Trade publications

Output: Universe of 500-2,000+ companies

Bottom-Up Relationship-Driven

Approach: Identify targets through relationships and expertise

Sources:

  • Industry conferences and events
  • Advisor and investor networks
  • Customer and partner relationships
  • Former colleagues and industry contacts
  • Board member networks

Activities:

  • Attend industry events
  • Join trade associations
  • Cultivate relationships with intermediaries
  • Maintain active network in target sectors

Output: 20-100 high-quality relationship-driven targets

Hybrid Approach (Recommended)

Combine top-down systematic screening with bottom-up relationship development for comprehensive coverage.

Creating the Long List

Filtering Criteria

Must-Have Criteria (eliminating factors):

  • Industry/sector alignment
  • Geographic location
  • Revenue/EBITDA size range
  • Business model compatibility
  • No obvious deal-breakers (regulatory, competitive, etc.)

Nice-to-Have Criteria (scoring factors):

  • Growth rate and trajectory
  • Profitability and margins
  • Market position and share
  • Technology and capabilities
  • Management team quality
  • Cultural fit indicators
  • Customer base quality

Screening Process

Step 1: Automated Screening (Universe → 200-500 companies)

  • Apply hard filters (size, geography, sector)
  • Use databases and software tools
  • Remove obvious non-fits

Step 2: Desk Research (200-500 → 50-100 companies)

  • Review websites, LinkedIn, press releases
  • Check financial databases
  • Read news and industry reports
  • Assess strategic fit and attractiveness

Step 3: Preliminary Scoring (50-100 → 20-30 companies)

  • Score against weighted criteria
  • Rank by priority
  • Identify information gaps

Output: Prioritized long list of 20-30 companies

Developing the Short List

Deep Research Phase

For each company on the long list, conduct comprehensive research:

Business Model Analysis:

  • Products/services and pricing
  • Customer segments and go-to-market
  • Unit economics and scalability
  • Competitive positioning
  • Growth drivers and trajectory

Financial Analysis:

  • Revenue and growth trends
  • Profitability and margins
  • Cash flow characteristics
  • Capital requirements
  • Historical performance

Market Assessment:

  • Market size and growth
  • Competitive landscape
  • Barriers to entry
  • Regulatory environment
  • Technology trends

Strategic Fit Evaluation:

  • Alignment with M&A strategy
  • Synergy potential (revenue and cost)
  • Integration complexity
  • Cultural compatibility indicators
  • Risk assessment

Information Gathering Tactics

Public Sources:

  • Company website and blog
  • LinkedIn (company page, employee profiles)
  • Glassdoor (culture and compensation insights)
  • Press releases and news articles
  • Industry reports and analyses
  • Regulatory filings (if applicable)
  • Patent databases

Semi-Public Sources:

  • Customer case studies and testimonials
  • Conference presentations and videos
  • Podcast interviews with founders/executives
  • Industry event participation
  • Awards and recognition

Proprietary Research:

  • Customer and partner interviews
  • Former employee conversations
  • Competitive intelligence
  • Channel checks
  • Expert networks
  • Job postings analysis (growth signals, capabilities)

Preliminary Valuation

For short list companies, develop rough valuation estimate:

Approach:

  • Identify comparable companies or transactions
  • Apply relevant valuation multiples
  • Estimate revenue and EBITDA
  • Calculate rough enterprise value range
  • Assess affordability and return potential

Output: High-level valuation range (e.g., "$50M-$75M")

Prioritization

Rank short list companies by:

  • Strategic fit (1-5 score)
  • Attractiveness (1-5 score)
  • Feasibility (1-5 score)
  • Urgency (1-5 score)

Output: Prioritized short list of 5-15 companies

Pipeline Tracking and Management

CRM Systems for M&A

Dedicated M&A Tools:

  • CorpDev.Ai: AI-powered deal sourcing, pipeline management, and zero-entry CRM
  • Affinity: Relationship intelligence and deal pipeline
  • DealCloud: Purpose-built for deal management
  • SourceScrub: Deal sourcing and tracking
  • 4Degrees: Relationship-focused deal CRM

General CRMs Adapted for M&A:

  • Salesforce: Highly customizable
  • HubSpot: Good for smaller teams
  • Airtable: Flexible database approach

Minimum Required Features:

  • Company records with key data fields
  • Stage tracking and pipeline views
  • Activity logging (calls, meetings, emails)
  • Document storage
  • Task and reminder management
  • Reporting and analytics

Key Data Fields to Track

Company Information:

  • Company name and website
  • Industry and subsector
  • Headquarters location
  • Founded date
  • Number of employees
  • Key products/services

Financial Data:

  • Estimated revenue
  • Estimated EBITDA
  • Growth rate
  • Funding raised (if applicable)
  • Ownership structure

Contact Information:

  • Key executives (CEO, CFO, founders)
  • Email and phone
  • LinkedIn profiles
  • Relationship strength and source

Status Tracking:

  • Current pipeline stage
  • Last contact date
  • Next steps and timeline
  • Assigned team member
  • Priority level

Deal Evaluation:

  • Strategic fit score
  • Preliminary valuation range
  • Key risks and concerns
  • Synergy potential
  • Integration complexity

Pipeline Metrics

Activity Metrics:

  • Companies in each stage
  • Pipeline velocity (stage progression rate)
  • Time in each stage
  • Conversion rates between stages

Coverage Metrics:

  • Total addressable market coverage %
  • Number of active conversations
  • Relationship strength distribution

Quality Metrics:

  • Average strategic fit score
  • Estimated total pipeline value
  • Number of priority A targets
  • Age of opportunities in pipeline

Target Engagement Strategies

Proactive Outreach

When to Use: High-priority targets not actively for sale

Approach:

  1. Research and Prepare:

    • Understand company deeply
    • Identify key decision makers
    • Develop strategic rationale
    • Prepare "warm up" topics

  2. Initial Contact:

    • Leverage relationships for introduction if possible
    • Cold outreach via LinkedIn or email if needed
    • Focus on relationship building, not immediate acquisition
    • Offer value (industry insights, partnership opportunities)

  3. Relationship Development:

    • Regular touchpoints (quarterly or biannually)
    • Share relevant information and insights
    • Attend industry events together
    • Build trust and rapport over time

  4. Timing the Acquisition Conversation:

    • Wait for natural inflection points (funding needs, strategic challenges)
    • Position as strategic partner, not just buyer
    • Start with "strategic partnership" or "strategic options" language

Timeline: Typically 6-24 months from first contact to serious discussions

Reactive Opportunities

When: Target or intermediary initiates contact

Approach:

  1. Rapid Assessment:

    • Does it fit strategic criteria?
    • Is timing right?
    • What's the competitive dynamic?

  2. Fast Decision:

    • Decide within 1-2 weeks whether to pursue
    • Don't waste target's time if not interested
    • Maintain relationship even if declining

  3. Process Management:

    • Understand seller's timeline and process
    • Identify key decision points
    • Allocate resources appropriately

Timeline: Often 2-4 months from first contact to LOI

Intermediary-Led Processes

When: Investment banks or M&A advisors running formal sale process

Approach:

  1. Initial Materials Review:

    • Review CIM (Confidential Information Memorandum)
    • Assess strategic fit
    • Decide whether to submit IOI (Indication of Interest)

  2. IOI Submission:

    • Non-binding preliminary bid
    • Express strategic interest
    • Request management meeting
    • Outline general terms and structure

  3. Management Presentations:

    • Meet management team
    • Deep dive on business
    • Assess cultural fit
    • Refine valuation

  4. Final Bid:

    • Competitive bid process
    • Need to be at or near best price
    • Highlight strategic value and certainty

Timeline: Typically 2-3 months from CIM to final bid

Pipeline Stage Management

Stage 1: Universe (0-2 hours per company)

Activities:

  • Automated screening
  • Basic fit assessment

Criteria to Advance:

  • Meets basic size, sector, geography criteria
  • No obvious deal breakers

Stage 2: Long List (2-4 hours per company)

Activities:

  • Desk research
  • Website and LinkedIn review
  • Preliminary strategic fit assessment

Criteria to Advance:

  • Good strategic fit
  • Attractive business characteristics
  • Information available for evaluation

Stage 3: Short List (8-16 hours per company)

Activities:

  • Detailed research
  • Financial analysis
  • Preliminary valuation
  • Identify key contacts

Criteria to Advance:

  • High strategic fit score
  • Compelling opportunity
  • Ability to engage

Stage 4: Active Engagement (20-40 hours per company)

Activities:

  • Initial outreach
  • Relationship building
  • Exploratory conversations
  • NDA and initial data exchange

Criteria to Advance:

  • Mutual interest established
  • Target willing to engage
  • Preliminary fit confirmed

Stage 5: Due Diligence (100-500+ hours per company)

Activities:

  • LOI negotiation and signing
  • Comprehensive due diligence
  • Detailed valuation
  • Integration planning

Criteria to Advance:

  • Due diligence confirms thesis
  • Valuation supports investment
  • Deal structure agreed

Stage 6: Negotiation (50-200 hours)

Activities:

  • Definitive agreement negotiation
  • Final valuation
  • Board approval
  • Financing arrangements

Criteria to Advance:

  • Agreement on all material terms
  • Board approval obtained
  • Conditions to close satisfied

Stage 7: Closed

Post-Close:

  • Integration execution
  • Synergy tracking
  • Performance monitoring
  • Lessons learned documentation

Pipeline Health Metrics

Quantity Metrics

Universe: 500-2,000 companies

  • Ensures comprehensive coverage
  • Provides backlog for future years

Long List: 50-100 companies

  • Sufficient volume for filtering
  • Manageable for tracking

Short List: 15-30 companies

  • High-quality opportunities
  • 1-2 years of potential deals

Active Engagement: 5-15 companies

  • Realistic capacity for relationship management
  • Sufficient for 1-3 LOIs per year

Due Diligence: 2-5 companies

  • Reflects resource constraints
  • Provides backup options

Conversion Rates

  • Universe → Long List: 10-20%
  • Long List → Short List: 20-40%
  • Short List → Active Engagement: 30-60%
  • Active Engagement → Due Diligence: 20-40%
  • Due Diligence → Closed: 30-60%

Overall: ~0.5-2% of universe companies become acquisitions

Velocity Metrics

Time in Stage:

  • Universe → Long List: Instantaneous (automated)
  • Long List: 1-3 months
  • Short List: 3-12 months
  • Active Engagement: 6-18 months
  • Due Diligence: 2-3 months
  • Negotiation: 1-2 months

Total Time: First contact to close typically 6-24 months

Pipeline Review Cadence

Weekly Team Meetings

Focus: Active deals and near-term priorities

  • Deal updates
  • Next steps and blockers
  • Resource allocation

Monthly Pipeline Reviews

Focus: Full pipeline health and priorities

  • Review metrics and conversion rates
  • Reprioritize opportunities
  • Add new targets
  • Remove stale opportunities

Quarterly Strategy Reviews

Focus: Strategic alignment and long-term pipeline

  • Assess pipeline vs. strategy
  • Identify gaps in coverage
  • Adjust target criteria if needed
  • Senior leadership and board update

Common Pipeline Management Mistakes

1. Insufficient Top of Funnel

Problem: Short list too small, running out of targets

Solution: Maintain large universe, continuously add to long list

2. Stale Pipeline

Problem: Opportunities sitting unchanged for 6+ months

Solution: Regular pipeline pruning, force progression or removal

3. No Systematic Screening

Problem: Ad hoc, relationship-only sourcing

Solution: Implement systematic market screening process

4. Poor Data Quality

Problem: Outdated information, missing key fields

Solution: Regular data hygiene, assign ownership for updates

5. Lack of Prioritization

Problem: Treating all opportunities equally

Solution: Clear scoring criteria, ruthless prioritization

6. Neglecting Relationship Building

Problem: Only reaching out when ready to buy

Solution: Long-term relationship cultivation with key targets

7. Over-Reliance on Intermediaries

Problem: Only seeing broker-led processes

Solution: Balance proprietary outreach with intermediated deals

Best Practices

1. Systematic and Continuous

Pipeline building is an ongoing process, not a one-time project.

2. Quality Over Quantity

Better to have 10 excellent targets than 100 mediocre ones.

3. Relationship-First Approach

Build relationships before you need them.

4. Technology-Enabled

Use CRM and data tools to scale your efforts.

5. Cross-Functional Input

Involve business units, product, sales in target identification.

6. Track Everything

Capture all interactions and insights in your CRM.

7. Regular Pruning

Remove opportunities that no longer fit or are stale.

8. Learn and Iterate

Every interaction teaches you about the market—capture those learnings.

References

  1. M&A Strategy Framework - McKinsey
  2. Building M&A Capabilities - Bain & Company
  3. M&A Target Identification - Deloitte
  4. Deal Sourcing Strategy - BCG
  5. Corporate Development Best Practices - Harvard Business Review

Last updated: Wed Jan 29 2025 19:00:00 GMT-0500 (Eastern Standard Time)

← M&A Strategy Development Corporate Development KPIs & Metrics →